Fluffernutter Brownies Recipe - Brown Sugar Food Blog (2024)

Take an ordinary box of Brownie mix and turn it into something extraordinary and try these Fluffernutter Brownies made with peanut butter, marshmallow fluff, and Nutter Butter cookies.

This Fluffernutter Brownies recipe needs to go on your “must bake” list as quickly as possible.

I love taking something that people typically view and one dimensional, and make it in a variety of ways. I guess you can say I am known for doing that on my blog. You don’t believe me, you can take a look at my recipe roundup for dishes I’ve made using cake mix. I am all about making my life easier, not harder. I know when it comes to baking dishes a lot of you feel the same way.

When I am browsing for a recipe, the first thing I look at is the ingredients. If I have all of the ingredients or do they seem simple enough for me to buy. Second, I am looking at the cook, bake, and prep times to determine if its something I want to make. Finally, I read the instructions to find out how complicated the recipe may be and that typically seals the deal for me, especially when it comes to baking recipes.

Although a recipe looks easy and doesn’t seem like it would be complicated, you can come across a recipe that may require refrigeration time, setting time, or another crazy element to the recipe. However, when making a recipe from a cake mix, you can cut down a lot of time and still get the same result.

In case you didn’t know, I do have a Brownie recipe on my blog that you refer to, but sometimes I like using a Brownie mix when I am testing and trying out different Brownie recipes. Using a Brownie Mix for these Fluffernutter Brownies Recipe was definitely a good move if I must say so myself. Then I topped these brownies off with everything that has been kissed by angels such as Nutter Butter Cookies, marshmallow fluff, and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.

Doesn’t that sound amazing?

I was inspired to make these brownies for two reasons. One, I really loved these Fluffernutter Balls that I made a few years back. They were stupid addicting. Second, I feel these brownies will be perfect for The Big Game! They just seem like a “manly” brownie (don’t ask).

How I made these Fluffernutter Brownies

I started off making brownies from a brownie mix as it was instructed on the box. Then, I melted down some peanut butter and placed dollops around the brownie mix along with dollops of marshmallow fluff. I swirl it around the mix and topped it off with crushed Nutter Butter Cookies and roughly chopped Peanut Butter Cups. That’s all there is to make this Fluffernutter Brownies recipe.

When you bite into one of these brownies, there is just so much good stuff going on you don’t know where to start celebrating what’s going on. I know some of you may be thinking that these brownies must be too sweet because of everything that is going on here. Well, they surprisingly aren’t all that sweet! I mean, they are but it isn’t over the top. I made this Fluffernutter Brownies twice to test and let me tell you, they were nearly gone with the 24 hours I made them. Not by my household, of course, but by my husband’s friends who came over and DEMOLISHED THEM.Print